Bitten apple — the iRotten mark

iPhone. iPad. iRotten.

APPLE IS ROTTEN TO THE CORE

An attorney-led investigation into Apple's warranty repair denials — devices accepted in clean condition, then declared “damaged or modified” after Apple had them, shipped back unrepaired, with a four-figure bill to fix the damage nobody can show you.

What happened

A new iPad Pro — bought in May 2026 for $1,399 — lost its display five months later. No drop, no impact, no liquid. It was taken to the Apple Store at Walt Whitman, in Huntington Station, New York, under warranty. Apple's own Work Authorization, dated October 29, 2026, records the intake inspection:

“No signs of obvious damage or liquid damage.” Warranty status: In Warranty. Display replacement authorized at $0.00 due. — Apple Work Authorization, October 29, 2026

The iPad was shipped to an Apple repair depot. Six days later, on November 5, 2026, Apple wrote that its technicians had

“determined that your device has been damaged or modified in such a way that is not covered by the Apple Limited Warranty, an AppleCare service plan, or an Apple service program.” — Apple rejection email, November 5, 2026

Apple's repair record now lists the problem, without qualification, as “Cracked Display.” The internal template code on Apple's own rejection email reads CS_AC_RS_RMC_Abused — "Abused." The price to fix the damage that appeared while the iPad was in Apple's custody: $1,000. The iPad was shipped back unrepaired. Apple has never produced the repair file, never identified the damage, and never answered the demand letter.

Damage that is found only after a device is in Apple's custody is not the customer's damage. That is the principle this investigation is built on.

The pattern

This is not one customer's story. Our research has documented 16 consumer reports from 2009 to 2026 describing the same sequence — a device accepted in clean condition, then declared damaged, modified, or ineligible after it reached a repair depot — and that count is a floor, not a ceiling. The recurring mechanisms:

No court has yet adjudicated this exact clean-intake sequence. That is why the paperwork matters — and why we are collecting it.

Tell us your story

If Apple accepted your iPhone or iPad for warranty repair in clean condition and then declared it damaged or modified, quoted you a large sum, or sent it back unrepaired, we want to hear from you — especially if you still have your intake paperwork. The strongest accounts share three things: an intake record showing the device was clean, a later claim of damage made only after Apple had custody, and the paperwork to prove both.

Include as much of this as you can:

  • Your device, and when and where you bought it
  • What went wrong, and when
  • Where you took or sent it for warranty repair — store or mail-in — and the date
  • What your intake paperwork says about its condition
  • What Apple said was wrong after they had it, in their words if you have them
  • What Apple quoted you to fix it
  • How it ended — and whether the device came back worse than you sent it
  • Whether you still have the paperwork

Or write directly: richard@thedoglawyer.com